Bug #54441 [Com]: Traits - Visibility on alias names

Edit report at http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=54441&edit=1 ID: 54441 Comment by: php at stefan-marr dot de Reported by: php-svn at helio dot arq dot br Summary: Traits - Visibility on alias names Status: Assigned Type: Bug Package: Scripting Engine problem Operating System: Linux PHP Version: trunk-SVN-2011-04-01 (snap) Assigned To: gron Block user comment: N Private report: N New Comment: Interesting question. I suppose it could be legal (but obviously it is currently not implemented). It looks kind of ugly to me, since it is less concise. But well, all the traits use definitions should be declarative and orderless, so if it is possible to do something with two separate declarations then people might expect that it works. Not sure whether we want that... But anyway, a good catch, thanks. Stefan Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2011-04-02 18:14:36] felipe@php.net According to the actual grammar and implementation, the right way to do this is using: Foo::lol as protected dontKnow; Stefan Marr, is supposed to work the code as the bug reporter tried it? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2011-04-01 12:47:43] php-svn at helio dot arq dot br Description: ------------ I'm trying Traits in php-trunk version. In a give moment, I tried to change visibility in a alias trait's method. Test script: --------------- trait Foo { public static function lol() { echo 'Foo!'; } } class Boo { use Foo { Foo::lol as dontKnow; dontKnow as protected; } } $boo = new Boo(); $boo->dontKnow(); Expected result: ---------------- Fatal error: Call to protected method Boo::dontKnow() from context '' in %s on line %d Actual result: -------------- Foo! ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=54441&edit=1