Req #70378 [Com]: keyval (=effective value as array key) to complement strval/intval

Edit report at https://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=70378&edit=1 ID: 70378 Comment by: prog at alkaan dot com Reported by: rn at alpha9marketing dot com Summary: keyval (=effective value as array key) to complement strval/intval Status: Open Type: Feature/Change Request Package: Variables related PHP Version: Irrelevant Block user comment: N Private report: N New Comment: Hello, Same problem when defined keys are integers in quotes and others are strings. Example : $t = [ '15' => 'first', 'AZ78' => 'second']; var_dump($t); return : [15=>'first', 'AZ78' => 'second'] This is a problem when we want use strict comparison on keys : $compare = "15"; foreach($t as $key => $value) { if ($key === $compare) { return $value; } } in this example, we never return $value Thanks John Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2015-08-28 09:20:30] rn at alpha9marketing dot com Also of note the float-as-string-as-key case, as opposed to the actual float-as-key: php > $a = array("1.234" => 'kittycat'); php > var_dump($a); array(1) { ["1.234"]=> string(8) "kittycat" } I.e. one would expect php > var_dump(keyval("1.234")); string(5) "1.234" ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2015-08-28 08:52:32] rn at alpha9marketing dot com Description: ------------ PHP offers strval, intval, floatval, doubleval to manually coerce values to desired types. This eases strict comparisons with the === operator within a desired type domain. One omission is that one can not trivially cast a value as it would be (internally) when that value is used as an array key. PHP apparently casts booleans to integers when they are used as array keys. A subset of numeric strings (minus hex / octal literal strings, potentially others) is cast to integers, as are floats (truncated towards zero). NULL is converted to an empty string. There is currently no built-in function that exposes this special type coersion used for array keys to the programmer, though one would have to assume it exists somewhere in the PHP code and exposing it would require only an external interface without (much) additional logic. Expected result: ---------------- php > var_dump(keyval(NULL)); string(0) "" php > var_dump(keyval(false)); int(0) php > var_dump(keyval(true)); int(1) php > var_dump(keyval(-1.734)); int(-1) php > var_dump(keyval(1.734)); int(1) php > var_dump(keyval("12")); int(12) php > var_dump(keyval("0xA")); string(3) "0xA" php > var_dump(keyval("017")); string(3) "017" ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at https://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=70378&edit=1