#20472 [Opn]: Flood Fill problem after changing to 4.3.0RC1

ID: 20472 User updated by: smseidl@worldnet.att.net Reported By: smseidl@worldnet.att.net Status: Open Bug Type: GD related Operating System: RedHat Linx 7.2 PHP Version: 4.3.0RC1/3 New Comment: I have changed my image in a couple places to ensure that there was a solid line around the area I was issuing the flood fill. This has fixed the problem with the flood fill filling areas that I did not intend to be filled. Although the problem no-longer appears to be with the flood fill, I am curious at to why the two versions of php work differently. Was something changed in php (or the bundled gd) to require a more 'solid' line? Could this be a bug, or a un-intended side effect? Thanks for all the help that has been provided. Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-12-17 22:33:58] pajoye@php.net Hello, After a little test of imagefill, I can say it works as expected. We can invoke the bad quality of the original images (lines and noises) as a reason for this problem. I m waiting feedbacks for a final test with a clean & well formed images before closing (I hope :) this bug pierre ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-12-17 21:51:25] smseidl@worldnet.att.net I have updated the script to output the orginial image below the php edited image. The differences in the 2 images is the back ground. The back ground should be white, not red as seen in the image created with this link. http://www.wisnowmobileclubs.com:88/refresh.php I have been able to re-create this problem by running the two different scripts on both IE 6 and Netscape 6. If the images look the same, please do a full refresh of each page to force pull the image from the server rather than cache. Thanks ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-12-16 19:59:22] pajoye@php.net Hello, Can you provide the original image (in the original format) ? I saw little difference (well I expect differences while analyzing the 2 results). pierre ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-12-15 16:12:31] smseidl@worldnet.att.net To see the results of the different installations, please execute these pages. You may need to do a full refresh (Ctrl-Refresh) http://www.wisnowmobileclubs.com:88/refresh.php for Dev. http://www.wisnowmobileclubs.com/refresh.php for Prod. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2002-12-15 16:01:07] smseidl@worldnet.att.net Well, I have gotten everything to compile & make with using the --with-gd option. But I am still having a problem with the flood fill. With PHP 4.2.3 the flood fill works fine... with the new versions of PHP the flood fill does not work. I will try to create a script that can reproduce this. http://www.wisnowmobileclubs.com/picture.htm show the differences in the images. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ The remainder of the comments for this report are too long. To view the rest of the comments, please view the bug report online at http://bugs.php.net/20472 -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=20472&edit=1