ID: 15841
Updated by: sniper@php.net
Reported By: rha@juggernaut.com.au
Status: Open
-Bug Type: *Mail Related
+Bug Type: Mail related
Operating System: Linux
PHP Version: 4.1.2
New Comment:
reclassified
Previous Comments:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[2002-03-07 04:48:56] hholzgra@php.net
ok
1) blame qmail, it should know better ...
2) lets have SMTP as a default implementation
for Unix mail(), too, instead of relying
on external programs
the "it isn't broken, so don't fix it" argument
got even weaker right now ...
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[2002-03-06 14:58:38] rha@juggernaut.com.au
The point is that it is incorrect to send DOS line endings to a Unix
command line program.
Sending a message through qmail (for example) with \r\n line endings
results in extraneous \r's in the delivered email. qmail assumes the
user knows what they're doing and converts only the '\r' characters to
'\r\n'. So if you use '\r\n' it injects '\r\r\n' into the SMTP
conversation.
e.g.
Headers:
"X-1: test1\nX-2: test2\r\nX-3: test3\r\nX-4: test4:
Message:
Subject: test message
X-1: test1
X-2: test2^M
X-3: test3^M
X-4: test4
I notice that some mail readers sanitize the incoming message and strip
the extra \r's (e.g. Eudora) but Mozilla doesn't and only the first
extra header is displayed as a header while the others appear in the
body of the message.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[2002-03-06 12:28:00] hholzgra@php.net
i still do not see the point, even for unix/sendmail
even /usr/lib/sendmail will transfer the message
using SMTP, and during this step you will have
\r\n line endings anyway, or am i missing something?
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[2002-03-06 11:04:38] pcg-php@ais.cx
The Right Thing(TM), then, is to determine which method (direct or SMTP
injection) is being done. If SMTP, use \r\n. If direct, determine what
the OS' line terminator is (\r\n for Windows, \n for Unix, \r for Mac
(?!)) and use that instead.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[2002-03-04 05:36:24] hholzgra@php.net
on windows we *do* talk STMP ...
------------------------------------------------------------------------
The remainder of the comments for this report are too long. To view
the rest of the comments, please view the bug report online at
http://bugs.php.net/15841
--
Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=15841&edit=1