#36364 [Opn->Bgs]: Setting a class variable as a reference to a session variable breaks

ID: 36364 User updated by: andrew at andrewshell dot org Reported By: andrew at andrewshell dot org -Status: Open +Status: Bogus Bug Type: Session related Operating System: Windows and Linux PHP Version: 4CVS-2006-02-11 (snap) New Comment: Seems the servers it breaks on are with register_globals on it works with register_globals off. So it makes sense now. Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2006-02-11 01:26:33] andrew at andrewshell dot org Description: ------------ I'm trying to use a session variable in a class as a singleton. If the session var doesn't exist I create it as an empty array. Once it exists I assign it by reference to a class variable. The functions of the class reference the class variable. Since the class variable is a reference to the session variable the class variable should exist between page refreshes. This works sometimes. On some server/php configurations it always works on others it always breaks. If the session variable key is named the same as the class name it breaks. If it's a random string it works. Might be related to Bug #28144 but that was fixed in 4.3.6 and this is broken seemingly with 4.4.0 and later. Here are configurations that work and ones that break: Breaks on: Microsoft-IIS/6.0 as ASAPI with PHP 4.4.0 Microsoft-IIS/5.1 as CGI/FastCGI with PHP 4.4.1 and 4.4.2 Apache/1.3.33 as CGI with PHP 4.4.2 Microsoft-IIS/5.1 as CGI/FastCGI with 4.4.x-dev snapshot 2/10/2006 Works correctly on Microsoft-IIS/6.0 as CGI/FastCGI with PHP 4.3.6 Apache/1.3.34 as Module with PHP 4.4.2 Reproduce code: --------------- http://andrewshell.org/test.php <-- Shows the error http://andrewshell.org/test.phps <-- source code First time you hit the page it works with 1 value set to each instance of the code. If you hit refresh the first two break and the third one works. Expected result: ---------------- All three instances should behave in the same way with results after several refreshes looking like: Array ( [0.20239000 1139615291] => 5 [0.46027100 1139615292] => 7 [0.50540700 1139616583] => 0 [0.31605700 1139616584] => 2 [0.59282400 1139616649] => 6 ) Actual result: -------------- The first two instances (blah and blah2) return with: Warning: Cannot use a scalar value as an array in /home/.untouchables/shellab/andrewshell.org/test.php on line x blah Object ( [data] => blah Object ( [data] => *RECURSION* ) ) after the first refresh. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=36364&edit=1