Bug #9250 Updated: Nested Functions are BAD, they make for inefficient debugging

ID: 9250 Updated by: jan Reported By: dsifry@linuxcare.com Old Status: Open Status: Bogus Bug Type: Feature/Change Request Operating System: Any PHP Version: 4.0.4pl1 New Comment: brackets are used for other controll structures as well, so disabling nested functions do not solve the problem. ->bogus Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2001-02-14 04:10:46] dsifry@linuxcare.com If you have a missing close-bracket "}" somewhere in your code, the PHP parser tells you that the error is at the last line. If you have a multi-hundred or thousand line file, this makes life a bitch. Rasmus tells me that the reason for this behavior is because functions can be nested, which means that: function a { function b { } } is OK. This is a silly feature. Why do you have it, for scoping reasons? It means that you can't effectively tell where syntax errors occur. Suggestion: Either make nested functions turned off by default but you can turn them on with a PHP global variable, like $PHP_BIZARRO_NESTED_FUNCTIONS = 1; or have the parser syntax set up so that it marks where a possible syntax error occurred (IOW it sees a possible nested function, but it could also be a syntax error), and if it reaches the end of the file with a missing "}" or two, that it displays the location where it parsed the nested function. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=9250&edit=1