Doc #54618 [Opn]: bindValue always returns true

Edit report at http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=54618&edit=1 ID: 54618 Updated by: johannes@php.net Reported by: jakub dot lopuszanski at nasza-klasa dot pl Summary: bindValue always returns true Status: Open Type: Documentation Problem Package: PDO related PHP Version: 5.3.6 Block user comment: N Private report: N New Comment: PHP is a weakly typed language. Implicit casts happen all the time in PHP. Other erros often can't be caught until the statement is executed (either when the replacement is done with emulation, or when the data is sent to the server with native PS) Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2011-05-05 08:17:12] jakub dot lopuszanski at nasza-klasa dot pl Is casting 'a' to integer sane? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2011-05-02 07:31:01] frozenfire@php.net I passed this bug by the fine folks in ##php on Freenode, and TML mentioned that by providing a PDO::PARAM_* type, you're likely causing casting behaviour in the PHP engine. I believe an error will only arise in the case that casting doesn't provide a sane value. Do you mind doing some tests to see if errors arise for "non-sane" casting? ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2011-04-28 09:06:16] jakub dot lopuszanski at nasza-klasa dot pl Description: ------------ even if you $pdo->setAttribute(PDO::ATTR_ERRMODE,PDO::ERRMODE_EXCEPTION); the function bindValue (at least with MySQL driver) will not help you detect any type errors, duplicated calls, or binding to wrong parameter. Test script: --------------- Bellow is a part of my PHPUnit tests that confirm this ( i guess you can figure out that getSUT, gets system under tests, that is prepares a query from PDO object connected to MySQL database): <?php public function testBindValueAlwaysReturnsTrue(){ $s = $this->getSUT("SELECT 1 FROM users WHERE id=:id"); //this one is ok: $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue(':id',1,PDO::PARAM_INT)); //this one is not ok at all, as '1' is not integer. //moreover we already bound id $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue(':id','1',PDO::PARAM_INT)); //this is also bad to allow both :id and id $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue('id',1,PDO::PARAM_INT)); //1 is not a string $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue('id',1,PDO::PARAM_STR)); //'a' is not an integer $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue('id','a',PDO::PARAM_INT)); //null is surely not an integer: $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue('id',null,PDO::PARAM_INT)); //1 is not a null $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue('id',1,PDO::PARAM_NULL)); //13 is not a valid type of parameter $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue(':id',1,13)); //'atlantis' is not even mentioned in the SQL query string: $this->assertSame(true,$s->bindValue(':atlantis',1,PDO::PARAM_INT)); } ?> Expected result: ---------------- I would expect either more precise documentation which would list all cases for which bindValue returns false (I could not find any), or fixing the function, to return false in cases mentioned above. Actual result: -------------- function returns true whatever I do. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=54618&edit=1