Re: Re: Planning to translate PHP Manual into a book..

From: Date: Wed, 12 Sep 2001 21:17:01 +0000
Subject: Re: Re: Planning to translate PHP Manual into a book..
References: 1  Groups: php.doc 
Request: Send a blank email to phpdoc+get-969337547@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message
We have had the problem of people taking the manual and printing it w/o even mentioning the origin (was it in a german book?), and I do not recall what was the resolution (if any) in that case. More recently, at the OSCON, I saw a "PHP dictionary" (or something along those lines) from SAMS that looked eerily similar to the contents, errors and examples we have in the manual. I told the SAMS guy (and also the guy from the San Diego Tech bookstore) that a cursory looked at the book gave me impresion that it was just a nicely formatted *copy* of the on-line PHP manual, and that I was not sure if the authors of the book asker for permission, etc. The SAMS and the bookstore guys were dumbfounded, and they did not know this fact. I did not read the book carefully, so if you see it and do read it more carefully correct me if I am wrong. Hopefully some license better tailored to documentaion will help avoiding these rampant stealing of the work of others. --- Egon Schmid <eschmid@php.net> wrote: > Hojtsy Gabor wrote: > > > > > > > (and don't be afraid that making your stuff > free will > > > > > harm sales, it will most likely be the other > way round > > > > > making people buy the book instead of > printing out > > > > > the manual themselves) > > > > > > > > The same happened to some Hungarian books > (free online > > > > version and a book), and it works very well. > And see > > > > http://www.docbook.org/ > > > > > > Huh, do you mean Norman Walsh's book TDG? The > situation here is very > > > different from our case. Norman is the leader of > the DocBook effort and > > > he will receive money from the publisher. If you > read this online, > > > Norman gets no money. Anyway, DocBook is like > PHP a Open Source Software > > > and to publish a book is commercial. > > > > O'reilly published that book, you can also > download in many formats > > for free. This was what I meant. > > I know, I have this book but it is not free. You and > I have to pay the > publishere a fee and Norman will receive a small > portion from every sold > copy of this book. Sure, the DocBook online manual > is Open Source and > you don't need anything to pay if you wish to read > it online. A online > manual is a completly different thing as a published > book. You have to > pay for a printed book and the author can fill his > petty cash. I know > this isn't so bad, but I know examples and this > could be the worsed case > for every author. > > > > Tell me a publisher who publish a book and give > it away as gift. > > > > Kiskapu (the publisher of the first hungarian PHP > book) also > > published a Linux book, and made the contents > available online. :)) > > How many dollars or euros do have to pay and is it a > translated PHP > manual or have the author written that book from > scratch? > > > > If someone will translate the PHP manual and > publish it (through a > > > publisher), the original authors don't get > money. This is IMHO > > > plagiarism. > > > > You are Right. I meant that the same people > publishes who is the > > author. Hartmut said, that Angriawan should commit > his changes > > to the phpdoc team, and so he can publish that > book. It is > > not the same case, as you are talking about. I can > agree with > > you in the current case. > > To make the story short, it isn't allowed to earn > money with other > peoples work. > > -Egon ===== --- Jesus M. Castagnetto <jmcastagnetto@php.net> __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Get email alerts & NEW webcam video instant messaging with Yahoo! Messenger http://im.yahoo.com

« previous php.doc (#969337547) next »