Re: sessions
| From: | Justin French | Date: | Thu, 24 Oct 2002 14:21:33 +0000 |
| Subject: | Re: sessions | ||
| References: | 1 | Groups: | php.general |
| Request: | Send a blank email to php-general+get-121274@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message | ||
I agree with Jaime. The problems are out there, and documented. The fact
that you haven't had complaints isn't really a good argument for. AOL (and
many large ISP's) users' IP address can and will change from request to
request... grab an AOL account for a month and try it for yourself. I did.
Justin
on 25/10/02 12:06 AM, Jaime Bozza (jbozza@thinkburst.com) wrote:
>> Really? Your IP randomly changes when your surfing between say
>> yahoo.com and msn.com does it? While it is true that you can
>> force an IP change while your connected, I have not yet seen a
>
> Mine doesn't because it's fixed. But for the reasons I stated in my
> previous email, it may for someone else. In fact, I've *watched* a
> session's IP address flipflop back and forth when downloading data from
> one of our websites. There are products out there that multiplex dialup
> lines without using MPPP. How do they do that? They make multiple
> connections, each with their own IP Address, and then the unit load
> balances TCP/IP sessions across the connections. (One TCP/IP session
> will go out connection #1, the next out of session #2, and so forth)
>
>> I have been using an extra IP check in our sessions on a website
>> which get's somewhere in the area of 500,000 unique hits a month
>> and we have not had a single complaint of people's session's being
>> dropped.
>
> Perhaps the clients you have don't use the devices (or are on AOL, or
> have webcache devices). Perhaps the ones that have a problem just go
> away. There could be many reasons why you haven't had a complaint.
> Personally I find it easier to go somewhere else than complain to a
> website that I'm having problems with.
>
> I'm just pointing out the issues, I'm not forcing anyone to listen. :)
>
>
> Jaime Bozza
>
>