Re: [RFC][Vote] New Curl URL API

On 05/07/2022 00:34, Pierrick Charron wrote:

All recent discussions show that we are not even close to getting a consensus on how the new CurlUrl OO API should be done. After changing my mind 300 times in the last day, I decided to only propose the procedural implementation that stays consistent with other functions of the ext/curl to target 8.2. I know this is not the ideal scenario, but with 8.2 feature freeze in two weeks, this is I think the only approach that will not put us in a potentially bad/harmful situation for a better future with ext/curl.

I'm voting no on this one based on the discussions from R11. The deadline being close is not a good enough reason to rush a change like this that will be difficult to unwind later. I agree with some of the other comments made that it would be preferable to come up with a more generic solution that can be used by multiple components rather than something specific to Curl. Mark Randall