Re: Re: [VOTE] Intermediate Results

On 6-Oct-06, at 11:59 AM, Edin Kadribasic wrote:

I believe that most OO "strictness" fatal errors should be demoted to notices. * Changing function signatures in derived classes

I be wary of allowing this because in some instances method signature can drastically impact behavior for example foo(&$bar) {} vs foo($bar); I'd prefer to don't reduce this to E_NOTICE. (-1)

* Accessing non-existing class constant (print myclass::myconst)

+1 on this

* Creating class variables (myclass::$myvar = 1)

You are talking about creating static class variables (dynamic ones can already be created without even an E_NOTICE). I think if you need this done, why not create a property dynamically and then access it statically? I suppose you are using this is a means of having a global var, in which case you don't have a class instance to init a property with, but to me it seems like a misuse of the OO functionality, -1. Ilia Alshanetsky