Re: [RFC Proposal] var keyword deprecation/removal

Hi, Le 18/02/2016 20:10, Colin O'Dell a écrit :

Hello everyone, I'd like to propose an RFC to deprecate and eventually remove the "var" keyword. My understanding is that this keyword was kept in PHP 5 for backwards-compatibility with PHP 4. However, it's been 9 years since PHP 4 was discontinued, so I'd like to bring this topic up for review. Usage of "var" doesn't seem to be as widespread recently. I've done a quick search of several major projects and libraries and found that only a couple are using it. I personally haven't seen it used in any PHP 5.3+ project I've worked on in recent memory. Because "var" simply acts as an alias for "public", removing it should not cause any loss of functionality. Yes, it's a BC break, but developers can easily replace it with "public" to maintain the same functionality. PHP 7 deprecated PHP 4 style constructors in favor of the PHP 5 __construct() method. I'd like to propose doing the same for the "var" keyword - deprecate it in PHP 7.1 and remove it in a future version (7.2 or 8.0?) I'd appreciate any thoughts or feedback you may have, especially if you have any objections to me creating an RFC for this proposal. Best regards, Colin O'Dell

Writing an RFC about it is fine, but, IMHO, it should target version 8.0. As it was already said, deprecating it in 7.x would be probably more negative than positive. But, deciding today that it will be suppressed in 8.0, and leaving 5 years for devs to adapt their code, is something I would probably support. When discussing about PHP 7, we found a lot of changes that would have been possible only if they had been announced several years in advance. That's why I think that, even if we just released version 7, we can start discussing such changes for 8.0. Regards François