Re: Missing reflection info about strict types?

On Mon, Sep 5, 2016 at 1:13 PM, Nicolas Grekas <nicolas.grekas@gmail.com> wrote: > > Why do you concatenate these files in the first place? > > > > > > It's not specifically me but Symfony's ClassCollectionLoader::load() > method, which generates a single file with common classes inlined for > faster bootstrapping (the perf gain is objectively measurable). > > You give this method a list of classes that are always required, and it > computes all the required parents/interfaces/traits they use, by using > reflection of course. It turns namespace to the bracketed syntax, orderd > things as required (parents first), and dumps everything in one php file. > > The issue came to our tracker that this process was broken once one wanted > to inline a strict class there, either directly or indirectly through the > parent chain. > Again, there is not such thing as a strict class. You should be stripping ALL declare(strict_types=0/1) from the class files, and even if enabled it at the top of final generated file it wouldn't make any difference _unless_ you're calling the classes IN the generated file. Anything you include it into will decide for itself whether it is strict or not. > I worked on the issue and fixed it by replacing the inlining by a "require" > for now. > > Here is the pointer for the fix (then the class & the issue): > https://github.com/symfony/symfony/pull/19859/files?w=1 I would highly recommend using sprintf() instead of str_replace() to inject your regex. And again, strip the declare lines completely. Then you can concat. https://github.com/symfony/symfony/pull/19859/files?w=1#diff-e37b3a45b919f2dd526570353388e4a5R1 This isn't a class with strict types, it's a file that will enforce strict types on code that _it_ calls, not code that calls the class defined inside it. - Davey