Re: [RFC] Type hints

AG>>>AG>>nullable MyClass $a = 5 AG>>> AG>>>I must be missing something, but why typehinted variable should have any AG>>>default except for null anyway? If someone says "I want only MyClass AG>>>here!", why he should be able to put 5 there? AG>> AG>>Well maybe it's a bad example but he can put NULL instead of 5. Well, that was exactly my point, though not expressed explicitly: if you can put null there, you don't need 'nullable'. If you say 'MyClass $a', it doesn't allow null, if you say 'MyClass $a = null', it allows null. Or, other way around, if you say 'nullable MyClass $a', it defaults to null, otherwise it has no default. I think we should prohibit to put any default to typehinted variables except null in any case - since it doesn't make any sense except promoting code based on is_object checks etc. - the exact thing we wanted to avoid with typehints. -- Stanislav Malyshev, Zend Products Engineer stas@zend.com http://www.zend.com/ +972-3-6139665 ext.115