Re: Is PHP staying with the open source community?
| From: | Rasmus Lerdorf | Date: | Fri, 13 Oct 2000 22:13:14 +0000 |
| Subject: | Re: Is PHP staying with the open source community? | ||
| References: | 1 | Groups: | php.mirrors |
| Request: | Send a blank email to php-mirrors+get-2494@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message | ||
> I am not sure where you get the idea that the Zend Optimizer is such an
> important part of PHP?
>
> There is no objective numerical criterion for "important", but I've
> heard from people who feel that it is. I think they are justified.
>
> Practically speaking, the optimizer functions as a kind of compiler.
> When a system initially offers just an interpreter, and then a
> compiler is released which runs user programs faster, people generally
> consider that an important advance and consider the compiler an
> important part of the whole package. So if the compiler is non-free,
> that casts a shadow on the project as a whole. Besides, this is not
> an outside add-on; it is maintained by the same people who develop the
> interpreter.
No, it is maintained by 2 out of the core group of 9 people that develop
PHP. There is no stipulation anywhere that stops project members from any
free software project from writing non-free software at the same time. I
would personally prefer if the optimizer was a free software project and
would happily help create a free software project to replace this
commercial one. There are a lot of free software developers that write
proprietary code as their fulltime jobs and free software in their spare
time. Until the free software movement has won this war I don't see this
changing and I also don't see how we can exclude these people from
contributing to the free software community.
Also, if it was such an important component then there would already be a
project underway to replace it. The fact it that nobody has felt
motivated enough to create such a project.
> I am glad to learn that few people are using this proprietary program,
> but we cannot count on the situation to stay that way. The optimizer
> is still new, and people might still be starting to use it. If so,
> these figures might get worse in the near future.
That could definitely happen.
> I think we need to develop a replacement for Zend that is entirely
> free and has a GPL-compatible license.
I would personally prefer an Apache-style license, but I am in full
agreement that a free software replacement would be a good thing. And it
will happen when enough people feel that this is needed.
-Rasmus