Re: Applying for PHP mirror in Israel - il.php.net
| From: | Mivzakim.net PHP Mirror maintainer | Date: | Thu, 15 Apr 2010 14:40:16 +0000 |
| Subject: | Re: Applying for PHP mirror in Israel - il.php.net | ||
| References: | 1 2 3 4 5 | Groups: | php.mirrors |
| Request: | Send a blank email to php-mirrors+get-38116@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message | ||
On Thu, Apr 15, 2010 at 4:13 PM, Daniel Brown <danbrown@php.net> wrote:
> On Wed, Apr 14, 2010 at 23:41, mivzakim.net <mivzakim@mivzakim.net> wrote:
> >
> > We do deal with developing websites for others (and hosting them), and we
> > even provide VoIP services; It's true that we don't have a promotional
> > website to advertise the above (we prefer word by mouth), and instead we
> > provide a nice service to the community that provide live news...
>
> I believe that's probably true, at least in part. That doesn't
> mean it complies with our requirements, which were explicitly-stated
> in the first email you received from me.
>
>
If you say... :)
> > Quite frankly, even if we didn't deal with providing services to the
> > Internet, I don't see the issue here; The previous host of il.php.netwas
> > neither one of the requirements, and they were hosting the mirror for
> many
> > years; We have better hardware, more bandwidth, our own brand-made
> servers
> > with on-site service support by HP, sitting on the datacenter backbone of
> a
> > major ISP in our full control...
>
> That may be the case, but first of all, the mirror in place before
> was a provider prior to the requirement changes we made to our
> policies for admission into the program; thus, the mirror was
> "grandfathered-in" and was permitted to remain active. There are
> still a few others in our rosters who match the same, and there's a
> clue from your own statement as to why: "they were hosting the mirror
> for many years."
>
> However, despite the argument, I'm further baffled by your
> statement: how does a "major ISP in [your] full control" not have an
> Internet presence?
>
>
We are not a major ISP. We wanted to *host* the mirror on *our own servers*,
of which *we* have full control on, which are located in a major ISP's
datacenter;
Technically, if the ISP would host a PHP mirror, they will... take a server,
put it at the EXACT same place, connect it to the EXACT same network port,
and would give you the exact same service; OK, maybe not the same service;
Because we care a lot about PHP, and the ISP... well, we pay them $$$ and
could still welcome a better customer service :) And they'll probably care
even less for a service they donate to, had they donated...
> > Right no there is no active mirror in IL, which is really a shame.
>
> There is a mirror, but it is presently experiencing technical
> difficulties. I do, however, agree that it is a shame; it sounds like
> the service you would provide as a mirror would be a great asset to
> our global infrastructure.
>
>
Right, that's what we wanted to give. I am still not sure I understand the
logic behind this somewhat awkward policy (no other open source mirroring
requirements request this...)
> > Hope you'll change your mind.
>
> And I hope that you'll understand that it's by no means personal
> that I will not; if I make a concession for your mirror in this case,
> in fairness I must do so for others as well. It's against our
> policies, and those policies are for good reason. Again, I do
> apologize, but unless the sponsor and URL meet the requirements, we
> cannot accept your mirror into the program.
>
>
>
Like I said, I don't understand the policy. You say it's for a good reason;
I am not sure what the reason is (and b.t.w. why it's not stated on
/mirroring ?). I think that people who wish to donate you a service, should
be given an opportunity to do so; If you suspect their proficiency (I'm
merely guessing what the reason might be) - by all means - pass them through
rigorous testing. However, not having the title "ISP" as the sole reason for
an otherwise perfectly good mirror - not sure how this helps the community.
I am not saying we should be exempt from a policy; Policies are there to be
kept. I'm questioning the necessity of the policy itself. :-) And as a proof
I gave the example of existing mirrors who does not abide the current
policies, which we all enjoy(ed) from.
So... that's what I have to say, and that's what I meant by "change your
mind" - about the policy itself, not us in particular.
At any case, the mirror stays up, and we'll just throw il.php.net and
il2.php.net to our /etc/hosts file, so we can have PHP.net on a 2ms
roundtrip, instead of the current 225ms :|
(and of course anyone from il.* who wants to use a local mirror, is more
than welcome to do the same - we'll provide the service to anyone interested
regardless of being official or not - it's for the community! :) )
With the hope for a policy change in the future - Wishing you good luck!