Re: Re: cvs: pear(MAINT_1_1) /Net_NNTP package.xml

From: Date: Sat, 03 Dec 2005 17:47:47 +0000
Subject: Re: Re: cvs: pear(MAINT_1_1) /Net_NNTP package.xml
References: 1 2 3 4 5 6  Groups: php.pear.qa 
Request: Send a blank email to pear-qa+get-3306@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message
Greg Beaver wrote: > In this world of limited time, this is one of the most thoughtful messages I've read recently. Thank you for the time to write this. You are most welcome, and thanks for all your hard work on the installer! And while at it, please excuse if my reply had an irritated tone. Aside from being truly a bit irritated over the fact that I had to write an excuse for my current actions, I was a bit frustrated that you, of all the people involved in PEAR, was the one wasting you time on a developer apparently gone mad. Luckily for me it wasn’t the case =|;-D I must say that I’m a bit surprised that my reply should be one of the most thoughtful messages you have read recently! If that is the case, either you must be overburdened by tings like RTFM-questions and/or fruitless dialogs. If that is not the case the condition PEAR is currently in is worse than I would have imagined! > I happen to be one of those people who do not fear competition from Zend or any other source. If they write stuff that makes it possible for me to do my work faster and safer, hallelujah. Same here - it’s just a pity that the progress is on public display. They could at least post a short list of expected base content. I’ve only seen a listing of a CVS checkout, but it actually made me stop all work on some of my projects, since I don’t want to waste my time on writing a duplicate of the upcoming framework - I might end up continuing writing my own stuff though, but only if the end result is dissatisfying =|;-) > As for problems in PEAR itself, I think we have the same vision there as well when it comes to quality. Considering our previous dialogs I’m sure you are right !-) > I happen to agree with Arnaud that until we have a critical mass of developers who > > 1) think there is room for improvement > 2) think there is *hope* for improvement > > nothing will ever change. For this reason, I hope you stick around long enough to see that day come. How could anyone disagree on such obvious requirements? I for one lost hope for improvement when it became clear to me that there wasn’t room for improvement. I’m not completely gone yet, but I seriously doubt that I will end up putting any serious effort into the PEAR repository. On the other hand I’m most willing to try to regroup, and try to make a serious channel if Zend doesn’t end up doing the perfect job for us... > Incidentally, it was decided implicitly > that PEAR2 will be a rewritten version that supports only PHP 5/6, so that is an interesting vaporware idea that is coming closer to fruition, at least as an idea. What exactly is meant by PEAR2? In my opinion the PEAR package and the PEAR repository/channel don’t have to be one ant the same thing. Although I guess you’d be happy to leave PHP4, I personally believe that there is no reason to make such a rewrite of the installer etc. until need be. The current installer should be able to serve both the PHPv4 and PHPv5 users via channels, and the focus should be put into making a PHP5-orientated channel. I know that PEAR started as a common error handling project, but things have changed since then. Over time the Apache daemon became the Apache HTTPD daemon, because ‘Apache’ became the general umbrella on top of many different projects. The same I now true for PEAR. The old meaning: “PHP Extension and Application Repository” is now very inaccurate/misleading/obsolete, since the ‘E’xtensions have moved to PECL, and the ‘A’pplications never became a true part of the project. Through its installer PEAR has now become more of a “PHP Extension, Application and Repository installer” project (with a default channel with lots of gadgets). The time has come to acknowledge this, at take the needed actions! Greg Beaver wrote: > Heino H. Gehlsen wrote: > >>Greg, honestly I do in fact understand how and why you came to the conclusion that I had gone mad. I’ve updated the info on Net_NNTP’s package-homepage – the choice of words was properly the most misleading… > Thanks for this as well. And thank you for being confused by my words and taking proper action! Kind regards, Heino

« previous php.pear.qa (#3306) next »