Re: [pear-webmaster] Zend Info
| From: | Klaus Guenther | Date: | Sun, 12 Sep 2004 20:57:22 +0000 |
| Subject: | Re: [pear-webmaster] Zend Info | ||
| References: | 1 | Groups: | php.pear.webmaster |
| Request: | Send a blank email to pear-webmaster+get-3126@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message | ||
Tobias Schlitt wrote:
I personally think that the idea of the PEAR/PECL WhoIsWho is a great one and that it can support every single developer. For that, I would especially beg the PEAR Group to give a positive decision on that issue.A big +1 from me, as well. I very strongly agree with Toby. I would like to add that we (PEAR) should not feel obligated to provide everyone with access to the information. For example, those wishing to use the information for _commercial purposes_ should not have access. However, since Zend is the driving force behind PHP (ok, that may be a bit strongly stated) and they are trying to provide a free information site, I feel that they may/should have _access to more information than other companies_. Provided, of course, the users agree with providing their information. In addition, any opt-in list should be by website/company, not a carte-blanche for all sites with access to the method. Not exactly sure how to do this except perhaps checking permissions by requesting IP. It would also be possible to create a method for each site. For example, besides on Zend, I don't think I would want to provide information concerning my current job or whether I am looking for work. Trying to provide equal information to all interested parties is _not_ a good idea, even if it is inherent in the concept of open-source data. In other words, there should be a public RSS feed that would provide public information about PEAR users (basically name, username, email or link to email form, packages). Then individual sites will have access to additional information as permitted by the users. The opt-in should clearly state for each site exactly what information will be transmitted. It is unlikely that many will opt-in to sites that want very personal information such as DOB, even though if it is not directly displayed on Zend, that is a different matter. For example, I would feel much more comfortable if there was merely an auto-generated age passed rather than the full DOB. (Of course, that would not fully prevent a malicious site from noting the date that the age changes, but that would take up to a year to discover the DOBs of all users who volunteer their birthday info.) This said, I would not like additional information shown in the profiles on the PEAR website (with the possible exception of Zend certification). There is enough info shown. Hoping for a quick and successful solution, Klaus