RE: Announcement: Smarty 1.4.3 now available

From: Date: Wed, 20 Jun 2001 22:36:22 +0000
Subject: RE: Announcement: Smarty 1.4.3 now available
References: 1  Groups: php.smarty.general 
Request: Send a blank email to php-smarty-general+get-916@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message
These are good arguments. I'd like to hear some more feedback on this one from the list. We have to weigh the security threats of direct access to the templates_c directory (any exploits anyone can think of?) vs. the performance overhead of a check on each template (is it even a concern?, maybe .0001 seconds or something, I'll have to do a benchmark) hans@linux.gelrevision.nl wrote: > > On 20-Jun-01 Monte Ohrt wrote: > > Should Smarty be responsible for this security test? > > I wouldn't judge this. Being not only a hobby coder but also involved in bus. > project it's my job to make everything as secure as possible (whithin my > knowledge). > > > This is extra logic that must be put into every template page and checked for > > on every > > invocation of the script(s). It would hardly _ever_ be used, only when a > > person specifially knows the URL to try. > > As far as I can see it Smarty will be used for opensource projects a lot. It > has a great speed and it's not to hard to work with it. All these advantages > will be destroyed if some script kiddo will look at the source and do a search > on any newsserver for .tpl.php extentions. The fact that a lot of people will > be lazy (or not able to read the manual since English isn't their native tongue > ) will possibly result in installations where the template, template_c and > cache dir will be located within the webdir. > > > If you are worried about this > > security, it should be your responsibility to move the directories out > > of document root. > > > > I guess I don't like the idea of the logic overhead put into Smarty > > templates for such a small percentage of times it would actually be of > > use. Does this sound unreasonable? > > Since those dirs are the result of using Smarty I do think you should matter. > I've been on the list for a few weeks now and I havn't seen anyone mention it > before. Are they all using it within the webroot? > > It's no big problem for me to write an extended class that will be used with > phpreview to make it handle this issue but I think it would be good if it > would be a default. > > Regards, > > Hans

« previous php.smarty.general (#916) next »