Bug #67540 [Nab]: svn.php.net blocking Drupal?

Edit report at https://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=67540&edit=1 ID: 67540 Updated by: bjori@php.net Reported by: php dot net dot e at salvisberg dot com Summary: svn.php.net blocking Drupal? Status: Not a bug Type: Bug Package: Website problem PHP Version: Irrelevant Block user comment: N Private report: N New Comment: You are severely misunderstanding the argument from drupal.org - and if you weren't then you were actually breaking the license by downloading it like this "on-demand". That same FAQ even states that BSD license is OK. We will not be removing this block as it is in your best interest so we will continue to protect you from doing bad mistakes. Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2014-07-04 23:34:26] php dot net dot e at salvisberg dot com Thank you for the links! Since the issue has been identified and resolved, is there any chance that you could lift the ban? http://svn.php.net/repository/pear/packages/Mail_mimeDecode/trunk/Mail/mimeDecode.php contains a "BSD license style" license. drupal.org does not allow uploading content that is not under "GPL version 2 or later" (see https://www.drupal.org/licensing/faq#q4). The trunk version of mimeDecode.php is 8 months old, the one on GitHub 3 years, and the PEAR package 3.5 years. Downloading the trunk version seems to be the only viable option, even at the risks that you mention. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2014-07-04 22:46:20] tyrael@php.net it is still a bad practice, because there is no promise that we won remove/rename that file or change it's api in a way that it will be incompatible with the caller. so I fail to see why couldn't your friend just put that script into his package/app? btw. if anybody interested in the original reason for blacklisting drupal from svn.php.net: https://twitter.com/mgdm/status/432907801955147777 https://www.drupal.org/node/2193919 now they are using our json api to fetch the signatures: http://doc.php.net/downloads/json/php_manual_en.json ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2014-07-04 21:19:06] php dot net dot e at salvisberg dot com Thank you for your reply and comments. I'm sorry if we have caused you grief -- this was surely a bug and not intentional. I'm not sure why you call it "abusing" though. One Drupal module that implements a mechanism to download from your svn repository is https://www.drupal.org/project/include. There may be others besides it, and I don't know whether this is the one that ran away, but it's the one we were using. I see your point about downloading from the svn trunk. I guess, the original developer tried to automate retrieving the dependencies to make it as easy as possible to get up and running quickly without having to deal with pear install and having to wrestle with getting the dependencies to where his module can find them. In the case of Mail_mimeDecode, downloading from the trunk is probably appropriate though, because there is no current branch / release package. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2014-06-30 05:27:28] bjori@php.net I do indeed recall an issue where we had to block drupal installation from ddosin our svn repository. It is clearly not cool on your part to be abusing our repository like this - and its not very smart either, as a svn repository is not somewhere you should be sending your production users. Please use the normal download mechanism offered. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2014-06-30 00:14:28] php dot net dot e at salvisberg dot com Description: ------------ A Drupal module that I'm helping to maintain tries to download the following file: http://svn.php.net/repository/pear/packages/Mail_mimeDecode/trunk/Mail/mimeDecode.php I have no trouble downloading it using my web browser, but a user reports in https://www.drupal.org/node/2294753 that the request... GET /repository/pear/packages/Mail_mimeDecode/trunk/Mail/mimeDecode.php HTTP/1.0 User-Agent: Drupal (+http://drupal.org/) Host: svn.php.net ... fails with an HTTP forbidden notice. Indeed, I can easily reproduce that with wget (see Test script). Are you blocking the "Drupal" user agent? Why? Test script: --------------- # wget --user-agent=Drupal http://svn.php.net/repository/pear/packages/Mail_mimeDecode/trunk/Mail/mimeDecode.php Expected result: ---------------- --2014-06-30 02:06:43-- http://svn.php.net/repository/pear/packages/Mail_mimeDecode/trunk/Mail/mimeDecode.php Resolving svn.php.net... 213.189.17.212 Connecting to svn.php.net|213.189.17.212|:80... connected. HTTP request sent, awaiting response... 200 OK Length: 39143 (38K) [text/plain] Saving to: `mimeDecode.php' 100%[=================================================================================================>] 39,143 --.-K/s in 0.01s 2014-06-30 02:06:43 (2.69 MB/s) - `mimeDecode.php' saved [39143/39143] Actual result: -------------- --2014-06-30 02:01:51-- http://svn.php.net/repository/pear/packages/Mail_mimeDecode/trunk/Mail/mimeDecode.php Resolving svn.php.net... 213.189.17.212 Connecting to svn.php.net|213.189.17.212|:80... connected. HTTP request sent, awaiting response... 403 Forbidden 2014-06-30 02:01:51 ERROR 403: Forbidden. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at https://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=67540&edit=1