Bug #54236 [Opn->Bgs]: GtkNotebook does not always remove pages

Edit report at http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=54236&edit=1 ID: 54236 Updated by: auroraeosrose@php.net Reported by: ptlis at ptlis dot net Summary: GtkNotebook does not always remove pages -Status: Open +Status: Bogus Type: Bug Package: PHP-GTK related Operating System: Ubuntu 10.4 32bit PHP Version: 5.3.5 Block user comment: N Private report: N New Comment: This is entirely controlled "upstream" That is the gtk+ libraries decide how this is handled - if you think this is a bug in the gtk libraries please head to gtk.org and file a bug there Thanks! Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2011-03-12 13:27:56] ptlis at ptlis dot net Description: ------------ I can't find any documentation regarding how gtk+ handles notebook page removal; if the page indexes are meant to be re-ordered on page removal this bug is bogus. Pages are not always removed if you call GtkNotebook::remove_page(), and whether they are removed or not seems dependant upon the order in which the pages were appended / removed, see the below example. If the line to remove the 3rd page is moved from the last page to be removed to the first the below test case finishes successfully, in it's current configuration however it fails without error. Test script: --------------- <?php function removed(GtkNotebook $notebook, GtkWidget $child, $index) { echo "tab index $index removed\n"; } $window = new GtkWindow(); $window->set_size_request(400, 400); $notebook = new GtkNoteBook(); $notebook->connect("page-removed", 'removed'); $vbox = new GtkVbox(); $vbox->add(new GtkLabel('tab contents')); $tab1Index = $notebook->append_page($vbox, new GtkLabel('Tab1')); $vbox = new GtkVbox(); $vbox->add(new GtkLabel('tab contents')); $tab2Index = $notebook->append_page($vbox, new GtkLabel('Tab2')); $vbox = new GtkVbox(); $vbox->add(new GtkLabel('tab contents')); $tab3Index = $notebook->append_page($vbox, new GtkLabel('Tab3')); $vbox = new GtkVbox(); $vbox->add(new GtkLabel('tab contents')); $tab4Index = $notebook->append_page($vbox, new GtkLabel('Tab4')); $window->add($notebook); $notebook->remove_page($tab2Index); $notebook->remove_page($tab1Index); $notebook->remove_page($tab3Index); $window->show_all(); Gtk::main(); Expected result: ---------------- All three pages of the notebook should be removed & the page-removed signal should fire three times. Actual result: -------------- Only the first two pages are removed with two page-removed signals fired, the third removal fails silently. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=54236&edit=1