Re: Vote: Straw poll for P++ feasibility

On 16.08.2019 at 01:39, Peter Kokot wrote: > Off topic question/request if it's maybe possible and doable unless > I've missed something. Current RFC process is in short something like > writing a text document together with the implementation itself via a > pull request already and at the same time the discussion phase is > happening. After discussion there is a voting phase based on the > feedback from the comments. There, many times people who vote also > sometimes don't add reasons why they vote against something and they > stop the RFC from passing. RFC author, not only cannot implement it > but they also waste their time with the implementation. > > Would it be a good thing if the RFC author would have a similar option > to get voting results feedback before starting to code (implementation > phase) on the RFC? So, they can see the results before the voting > phase and if the time investment is worth the trouble of adding a > feature or not. It is not necessarily required to have an implementation for an RFC available, see item (6) in <https://wiki.php.net/rfc/howto>. -- Christoph M. Becker