Re: session_reset() and session_abort() to send errors

From: Date: Tue, 25 Mar 2014 16:06:29 +0000
Subject: Re: session_reset() and session_abort() to send errors
References: 1 2 3  Groups: php.internals 
Request: Send a blank email to internals+get-73428@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message
Hi, I had previously requested the removal of these 2 functions based on lack of discussion about them (or at least I found none). My request was ignored because I had to tell "why it's not needed", which I don't think is the right approach for a new feature that somebody just decided to commit, but regardless ... here's a good reason: From what I understand, session_reset() not only discards changes to $_SESSION and not just re-reads the data, but re-initializes the whole session. This includes calls to open(), read(), which include opening file pointers, setting locks, checking session ID validity, etc. I don't know how safe that is to do internally, but with a userland session handler, it means discarding previously open connections/file pointers, locks and whoever knows what else a developer might've cached, assuming that open(), read() would only be called once. It would've also been better IMO if the function was called session_restart() instead, because of the above-described behavior. I also don't like that these 2 functions kind of make sessions to look like a traditional database transaction, or at least I'd hate it to see code that uses them for the wrong purpose, but that's rather philosophical ... I do see them as useful for resetting the application to a certain state in case of an error, but in that context - session_abort() alone should be sufficient. Cheers, Andrey.

« previous php.internals (#73428) next »