Re: [PEPr] Comment on File System::S3

Hello On 06/12/2007, Bertrand Mansion <golgote@mamasam.com> wrote: > > Obviously Cesar's class was copied without great care. If Till knew > he was stealing public code, he would have at least modified the > comments, fixed the English mistakes and changed more, unless he is > silly? I personally believe him when he explains how he got to work > on the code. Truth Now I think he should add Cesar as author of his class since a lot of > code comes from him. But the package is now PHP5 and cleaner than > what is found on PHPClasses.org (although could still be improved). > Let's try to be constructive. If Cesar is interested he could even be > co-leader on the package. Both Till and Cesar sounds like nice persons. I can publish my code where I want, and if I have not publish my code on PEAR that should be for something. And why re-publish the same code on PEAR is that is free-available on other project-hosting? I was thinking all the day, and I think PEAR's people are so smart, and they will not approved the proposal, it would be other thing if the guy ask permission to port the code to pear, just for be friendly, or at least not modifying the copyright (you're legally free to do this) I saw on other message that he fix the code, is that true?, he just add some "private" "public", and change some constants name. I personally choose to develop the code for PHP4 and greater... that was not a bug. Other thing would be is he fix a big bug, or made useful changes for the open source community. -- > Bertrand Mansion > Mamasam > Work : http://www.mamasam.com > Blog : http://golgote.freeflux.net > > -- > PEAR Development Mailing List ( http://pear.php.net/) > To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php > > I will still work on the project to improve it, when I have a few of time, because right now I am having other important projects too ;) Saludos desde Paraguay! -- Best Regards Cesar D. Rodas http://www.cesarodas.com http://www.thyphp.com http://www.phpajax.org Phone: +595-961-974165