Re: pdo_db2 karma

From: Date: Fri, 07 Apr 2006 00:59:11 +0000
Subject: Re: pdo_db2 karma
References: 1  Groups: php.pecl.dev 
Request: Send a blank email to pecl-dev+get-3690@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message
Wez and the community, >>> And now you're (IBM) going to release you own driver anyway? >>> Can you clarify IBM's POV on this then? Our position on this issue is simply stability. We are very concerned with having a driver that works through PDO for DB2 that will be stable, or is as stable as possible. We want to be sure that bugs will be fixed with urgency when they come about for DB2. This is the sole reason for the PDO_DB2 creation. And also to add DB2 specific nuances that may not be applicable across the board of databases. >>> We can't contribute to your code without a CLA, and I've been keeping >>> people off my code because we've been unable to work out a process >>> between us. We have been working on resolving this internally. I have started internal communications on this topic with the appropriate groups. I will share these issues with them and we will work to expedite a solution to our issues. >>> If you're dead set on a pdo_db2 driver that we can't commit to either, >>> then I think it's time that you kept your code in your own CVS and >>> just publish the PECL packages to pecl.php.net. We are not dead set on anything besides a stable PDO driver for DB2. For now, I have removed the PDO_DB2 project page. We will work towards a more community based approach to fulfill our needs. At this point I am not sure whether that will be through PDO_ODBC, PDO_DB2, or something else. To reiterate, the reason for all of this has been our need for a stable PDO driver for DB2. The bugs we have been facing through PDO_ODBC (for example PECL bugs 6999 and 7054) has lead us to the PDO_DB2 route. We are dedicated to providing the community with a PDO based DB2 driver. I will keep in touch with you Wez and the rest of the PECL community with the results of our internal communications and progress. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Kellen Bombardier Software Engineer IM Common API Development - Lenexa IBM, 11200 Lakeview Dr. Lenexa, KS 66219 Phone: 913-599-7221 email: kfbombar@us.ibm.com ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "Wez Furlong" <kingwez@gmail.com> 04/05/2006 07:51 PM To Kellen F Bombardier/Lenexa/IBM@IBMUS cc pecl-dev@lists.php.net Subject Re: [PECL-DEV] pdo_db2 karma Now, I'm pretty pissed about pdo_db2 even existing. PDO_ODBC already has DB2 support and has been kept "clean IP" from day one with the hope that IBM will contribute. This is based on conversations with folks like Dan Scott. Because of this I've suffered all kind of flak from the other people working on the PHP project, and shouldered the burden of supporting this module entirely on my own. And now you're (IBM) going to release you own driver anyway? Can you clarify IBM's POV on this then? We can't contribute to your code without a CLA, and I've been keeping people off my code because we've been unable to work out a process between us. If you're dead set on a pdo_db2 driver that we can't commit to either, then I think it's time that you kept your code in your own CVS and just publish the PECL packages to pecl.php.net. We can remove your code from our CVS and remove the ACLs from the PDO_ODBC driver so that other open source folks can contribute again. Please clarify the situation. --Wez. On 4/5/06, Kellen F Bombardier <kfbombar@us.ibm.com> wrote: > I created a new project in pecl: pdo_db2. I created the pdo_db2 directory > in pecl/ but got the following error when trying to commit the files: > > >> cd pecl/ > >> cvs add pdo_db2 > ? pdo_db2/.cvsignore > ? pdo_db2/CREDITS > ? pdo_db2/EXPERIMENTAL > ? pdo_db2/Makefile.frag > ? pdo_db2/config.m4 > ? pdo_db2/config.w32 > ? pdo_db2/db2_driver.c > ? pdo_db2/db2_statement.c > ? pdo_db2/package.xml > ? pdo_db2/pdo_db2.c > ? pdo_db2/php_pdo_db2.h > ? pdo_db2/php_pdo_db2_int.h > ? pdo_db2/tests > 62001 LOGINFO pecl-cvs@lists.php.net kfbombar pecl/pdo_db2 - New directory > 62001 bailing > Directory /repository/pecl/pdo_db2 added to the repository > >> cd pdo_db2 > >> cvs add db2_driver.c > cvs add: scheduling file `db2_driver.c' for addition > cvs add: use 'cvs commit' to add these files permanently > >> cvs commit -m "Initial Version" db2_driver.c > **** Access denied: insufficient karma (kfbombar|pecl/pdo_db2) > Contact pecl-dev@lists.php.net for access to pecl/pdo_db2 > > Can I get the sufficient privaleges to add the files to pecl/pdo_db2. > Thank you. > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > Kellen Bombardier > Software Engineer > IM Common API Development - Lenexa > IBM, 11200 Lakeview Dr. Lenexa, KS 66219 > Phone: 913-599-7221 > email: kfbombar@us.ibm.com > ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- >

« previous php.pecl.dev (#3690) next »