Re: pdo_db2 karma
| From: | Wez Furlong | Date: | Fri, 07 Apr 2006 22:35:21 +0000 |
| Subject: | Re: pdo_db2 karma | ||
| References: | 1 2 | Groups: | php.pecl.dev |
| Request: | Send a blank email to pecl-dev+get-3694@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message | ||
On 4/6/06, Kellen F Bombardier <kfbombar@us.ibm.com> wrote:
> Our position on this issue is simply stability. We are very concerned with having a driver
> that works through PDO for DB2 that will be stable, or is as stable as possible. We want
> to be sure that bugs will be fixed with urgency when they come about for DB2. This is
> the sole reason for the PDO_DB2 creation. And also to add DB2 specific nuances that
> may not be applicable across the board of databases.
As we discussed on IRC the other day, having two pieces of code that
are > 90% the same maintained by two people that are not legally
allowed to communicate code between them doesn't help either piece of
code. Bugs fixed in one will require the same effort to be fixed in
the other, and likely be implemented differently, perhaps leading to
even more subtle problems longer term.
I've got absolutely no problem adding conditional DB2 specific code to
PDO_ODBC to handle any nuances that can not be covered by any more
generic means.
> >>> If you're dead set on a pdo_db2 driver that we can't commit to either,
> >>> then I think it's time that you kept your code in your own CVS and
> >>> just publish the PECL packages to pecl.php.net.
>
> We are not dead set on anything besides a stable PDO driver for DB2. For now, I have
> removed the PDO_DB2 project page. We will work towards a more community based
> approach to fulfill our needs. At this point I am not sure whether that will be through
> PDO_ODBC, PDO_DB2, or something else.
Having a single code-base that we can colloborate on seems like step
in the right direction.
PDO_ODBC has been kept "IP-clean" with that in mind, with a lot of
features and fixes worked out in a DB2 environment first before
testing in other environments.
> To reiterate, the reason for all of this has been our need for a stable PDO driver for DB2.
> The bugs we have been facing through PDO_ODBC (for example PECL bugs 6999 and
> 7054) has lead us to the PDO_DB2 route. We are dedicated to providing the community
> with a PDO based DB2 driver.
I think I've fixed problems related to those issues recently in PDO
and PDO_ODBC. Again, it does feel like we'll be duplicating each
others efforts if the code remains in two different places.
> I will keep in touch with you Wez and the rest of the PECL community with the results
> of our internal communications and progress.
Thanks,
--Wez.