Re: [RFC] isReadable/isWriteable property reflection

Hi Am 2025-12-17 16:26, schrieb Larry Garfield:

* We have decided on an approach for magic methods. The updated RFC text explains it in more detail, but in short, "if __isset(), then use that to determine readable. Otherwise, __get() implies readable. __set() implies writeable." That should handle the use cases Nicolas was interested in.

That works for me. I didn't feel particularly strongly either way.

We consider the RFC feature complete at this point. Baring any further substantive discussion, expect a vote in January after the blackout period ends.

I don't have further comments about the semantics themselves, but have one further clarification question:

The property has not been unset(). If it has, follow the same __isset check as above

Should this read “the same __get check” instead? And one note with regard to process: Don't forget to add a link to the discussion (https://news-web.php.net/php.internals/129101) to the RFC. Best regards Tim Düsterhus