Re: Re: [RFC] [Re-proposed] Adopt Code of Conduct

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 Hello everyone ! It's my first mail here and before writing anything else I'd like to say that I'm thankful to Anthony and Derick for carrying this RFC. Now… I have one issue with this argument : Chase Peeler a écrit le 22/01/2016 19:15 : > 3.) Finally, I think a Code of Conduct that includes punitive > measures is a bad idea. I won't go into details on why, as we've > gone over them in detail, but I'll sum it up as follows: a Code of > Conduct that gives a small group of people the ability to punish > others is open to abuse. I'm not saying that anyone proposing such > a code of conduct has evil intentions, or even that anyone on this > list would purposely act in an evil way if a member of the > committee. In fact, the reason I feel such Codes of Conduct is > dangerous is that someone acting in what they feel IS a noble way > can easily do the opposite. I think it falls in the « perfect solution » fallacy. We have the current situation, which is already open to abuse (see the repeated references towards « the toxicity of internals ») and because such abuses can still happen with a Code of Conduct and the team in charge of watching its application you consider that it is a bad idea. Furthermore, the abuses that may be perpetuated by such a team are already limited by the « Accountability » paragraph of the RFC : « The PHP project voting body has the right to overturn any action taken the Community Mediation Team by vote (50% + 1 required to overturn). » Respectfully yours, - -- Alda Marteau-Hardi XMPP: alda@leetchee.fr | Web: http://aldarone.fr/ GPG: 0xC2F8A5C7 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v2 iQEcBAEBCAAGBQJWonvuAAoJEDKPoMbC+KXHeTQH/RdpxlejsT9tg3u42lrIvpQs GiJ2nK8sTJvTfu2Mz6JGpFTwcIzFrw3h2xy8vRInuHHn8nx1mdDJL2lb1AhnlXjm bB2rZCAjj/I6Z5+YiAehRqm2fHoye+qEu72Q4Temea8bQGwHmQZXtVG+NIbH+lU/ nFTEUfAodtDTUfowXbDj3qQGnvyLYnmH0Uzvl9oEK8AkUpAqRzKCyA88O9hBhCwy Sy6Pqu1YC7O+7ZuTb7x5Y6FG0c9dMFMIzDsayPGhavyt95AQY/GdDqFnAZNZhQAE 73ktZTBNf9AKB/0BfJ3KbFiEP39iZiEEgOhrXa/k2aJoXzl8C7iLJh9Nli/Kh/s= =OA7I -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----