Re: PEPr status - Request for a new one

On Wed, 2009-06-10 at 08:40 +0200, Laurent Laville wrote: > Hi PEAR web team, > > Because myself I hate to see a proposal changed from proposal status to > call for votes suddenly, without leave a chance to post a comment. > > As it's done with change status phase from proposal to call for votes: > there are at least a one full week period. > > I propose to add a new status or change the old one, and send (of course > an email to pear-dev mailing list) by : > > - the proposal will be call fo votes in 1 week > > What do you think of this request ? This is not a bad idea. I think the issue it is trying to solve is getting people to leave feedback _before_ a proposal is voted on. Perhaps this could be done better by automatically mailing pear-dev with reminders about proposals that are open for comments and have no comments. That way, you won't have to threaten to call for votes just to get people to comment on your proposal :) Cheers, Mike