Re: cvs: phpweb / copyright.php license.html style.css /include layout.inc
| From: | Colin Viebrock | Date: | Wed, 11 Apr 2001 17:27:06 +0000 |
| Subject: | Re: cvs: phpweb / copyright.php license.html style.css /include layout.inc | ||
| References: | 1 2 | Groups: | php.mirrors |
| Request: | Send a blank email to php-mirrors+get-4696@lists.php.net to get a copy of this message | ||
> actually, i intentionally didn't include a copyright notice.
> i find the one you've put up completely unacceptable.
Ok, let's change it so it is acceptable.
> > <LI>The documents and information may be used solely for personal,
> > informational, internal, non-commercial purposes.
>
> why only non-commercial purposes?
Someone takes the entire PHP manual, turns it into a book, and sells it.
Do we want to allow that?
> personally, i can live with copycats. i don't think it really
> harms us, and they're the ones who end up looking stupid.
I mostly agree (especially about them looking stupid). PHP is so much more
entrenched now than when we started the last new look to the site.
However, it does erode our image if everyone starts copying the site. Not
to mention if some porn/hate/whatever site decides to co-opt our look and
graphics.
We need to make some effort to protect our image now. If we don't, then it
becomes that much harder to later on.
(Plus I don't want some company making money off the work/time we've
*donated* to developing the PHP site.)
I'm perfectly happy with a very liberal notice that basically says:
- do what you want with the content (can you GPL content?)
- except don't use the logo without permission
- give credit where it's due, please
- don't copy the look or graphics from the site, please
Can we come up with some acceptable wording that covers this? I offer the
following:
The code, text, PHP logo, and graphical elements on this website
and the mirror websites (the "Site") are Copyright © 2001
The PHP Group. All rights reserved.
Except as otherwise indicated elsewhere on this Site, you are free
view, download and print the documents and information available
on this Site subject to the following conditions:
- You should credit The PHP Group for any reproduction of
the documents and/or information from this Site.
- You may not remove any copyright or other proprietary notices
contained in the documents and information on this Site.
- The rights granted to you constitute a license and not a transfer
of title.
- The rights specified above to view, download and print the
documents and information available on this Site are not applicable
to the graphical elements, design or layout of this Site. These
elements of the Site are protected by trade dress and other laws
and may not be copied or imitated in whole or in part.
--
Colin