Re: [RFC] Typed Properties

2018-07-10 11:18 GMT+02:00 Marco Pivetta <ocramius@gmail.com>: > It's been a few weeks since this has first landed here, and we're just > wasting time in relatively silly discussions at this point: > > - As I said earlier, this patch has already been tested against some > extremely tricky scenarios, so from a userland perspective it is safe for > inclusion. If you don't have confidence in something related to it, please > write a test case and help out. > - can we get a yes/no from the RMs on whether we'll have the time window > to (potentially) get this voted and (*if* passed) merged? Shoot out a mail > with the decision, please. We could have a vote for which version to > include this in, if that's really such a big issue. > - can we split out discussions on 8.0 scope? Minor versions are indeed for > features. If PHP 8.0 lacks interesting/marketing features, that's a > different story. > - Nikita/Bob: can this be voted upon right after the RMs have taken a > decision? Anything blocking missing? > - Is the reference issue reported by Nicolas a blocker? Nicolas, can you > clarify here? > I'm definitely ith you on this one Marco, typed properties is something userland asks since a long time and postponing it to 8.0 for "marketing" reasons might be very frustrating (well, we'll deal with that if it happens :) ) But technically, it feels almost ready. The reference issue looks "easy" to fix(esp. when its not me doing it yes ;) ). It'd be better to have it at the same time, but I can wait the next version as I don't want to be the one with a blocker here, and also because I can write a "degraded mode" for now if that's the plan. Nicolas