RE: [PEAR-DEV] Package proposal: Mail_Mime (alternative)

> From: Heino H. Gehlsen [mailto:heino@gehlsen.dk] > Sent: Tuesday, August 19, 2003 7:50 AM > > > > > ther like to know what it is you dislike about my proposal... > > > > > > -1 indeed. > > > > -1 here, as I discussed this point with Richard and fully agreed with > > him here. > > > I didn't call for at vote, and there is no way I would call for such a > vote - I only pointed out that there had not been any formal rejection of > my > proposal. I asked for comments (any comment), but no, only -1. What I now > find rather strange is that while the proposal is discussed in private, > I've > heard only heard: "I don't like the code". Now I don't think that's > fair... I don't know enough about the internals of either approach to really tell, nor do I have the time to dive into it. It seemed to me that both of you put forth reasons that seemed sound to an outsider. It seems that since you both disagree that these features will not make it into Mail_Mime atm. However it seems to me that Richard explained his reasoning. I would therefore not say that his -1 is "unfair". Therefore it is now your turn to convince other people that your package should make it into pear as an alternative. And then there is of course the possibility of taken the package somewhere else. Regards, Lukas