Re: Comments on bugs marked bogus

Alexey Borzov wrote:

Hi, Scott Mattocks wrote:

From http://pear.php.net/pepr/pepr-proposal-show.php?id=60 "If any QA related issues are found in a package that QA has not been granted permission to change without consulting the maintainer,the QA team will file a bug report. If the issue remains unresolved for 1 month (2+1+1 weeks; see below), QA may fix it themselves."

In case you don't actually have a clue. The issue *is* resolved: the bug is closed as Bogus since January because the bug is not within QuickForm, but within the __autoload() code.

The current maintainer is recommending hackish fixes and supressing errors instead of fixing the current code. I would much prefer to keep my code clean and readable. If you cannot or will not resolve this issue please let me know.

I would prefer you keeping your code clean and readable by removing any references to QuickForm from it. You may also consider forking, but I honestly doubt you have the necessary skills to maintain a fork. Being in outsider in this just seems like a stupid argument to be having.

PHP5 is case sensitive, so we should start using case when calling is_a, etc to be forward compatible. If thats too big of an issue you could just say that quickforms isn't supported under PHP5. Anyhow its a less then one line fix that only invloves changing case. Also the initial comment of "bullshit" makes me think there is some sort of hate for this user going on, and thats really not the type of thing that should be happening in PEAR. -josh