Re: Re: [RFC] [Draft] Adopt Code of Conduct

Hi, Le 06/01/2016 16:21, Anthony Ferrara a écrit :

I have received no less than 4 direct threats of violence that were directly due to my involvement

with the Scalar Type Declarations RFC.

I'm surprised it went to that point but I'm glad you're talking about the STH saga, because this is a good example, still fresh in memories. So, let's analyze what happened when I was accused of 'sabotage' and 'strong-arming' because I had sent a supposedly offending mail to Sara. In my reply, I published the mail in question so that everyone could judge by itself whether it was offending or not. I'm glad we didn't have a PHP official SJW team because it would have probably denied me the right to publish the message, for confidentiality reasons. So, instead of putting the case in the public space where everyone could see that the accusation was highly exagerated, I would have been judged by 5 people who could have banned me on subjective matters (let's not underestimate cultural differences here). So, I'm all for a mediation team, but no sanction, even temporary, without a public vote. Regards François